Regular diners carry a set of beliefs about restaurants that feel like common sense and are mostly wrong. They shape when people arrive, what they order, and what happens to the food that goes home in a box. Sorting them out makes every meal after this one a little better.
Myth one: takeout is always faster than eating in
Takeout skips the table, not the kitchen. Your box waits in the same ticket line as every seated table, and on a Friday night that line is long. Ordering takeout at the peak of the rush and expecting it in fifteen minutes misunderstands where the time goes: cooking, not seating. The reliable way to get takeout fast is to order it before the rush or well after, and to order dishes that travel: baked items, sandwiches, and pizzas hold up; dressed salads and fries do not.
Myth two: leftover pizza is a lost cause
- Store it cold and flat. Slices stacked in foil or a container, refrigerated the same night, keep their structure for days.
- Reheat in a dry skillet. A slice in a covered skillet over medium-low heat crisps the bottom while the lid's steam revives the cheese.
- Or use a hot oven. Five to eight minutes on a preheated sheet pan restores a calzone or stromboli slice wrapped loosely in foil.
- Skip the microwave when you can. It heats unevenly and turns crust soft. It is a last resort, not a method.
Myth three: the best order is whatever is most popular
Popularity measures familiarity, not fit. The most-ordered dish at a grill may be a burger, but if your table wants a long dinner with courses, a pasta plate serves the evening better. Wide menus exist because tables differ. At Court Street Grille the menu runs from Greek salads and gyros to baked ziti and strombolis in the same kitchen, and the right order is the one that matches your table's appetite and schedule, not the room's average.
Myth four: a short menu means a better kitchen
Sometimes, in a tasting-menu room. In a downtown family restaurant, a wide menu is the business model: grandparents, kids, coworkers, and couples all need a plate in the same meal. The question is not how long the menu is but whether the kitchen's range shares a logic. Dough, grill, and salad station work in this kitchen all share ingredients and equipment, which is how a menu can run wide without running thin.
One more belief worth retiring
The last myth is that a regular's order is a rut. Watch the people who eat in the same room every week: they order the same plate because they have run the experiment the rest of us are still running. They know which dish the kitchen makes best on a busy night, which side holds up, and which dessert is worth saving room for. Their loyalty is data, not habit.
There is a practical way to borrow that data on a first or second visit: ask the server what the kitchen is proudest of and what the regulars order, then actually order it. Servers answer this question honestly because it makes their night easier when you like your food. The most popular dish and the staff's dish are often different, and the gap between the two answers is the most useful menu information you will get all night.
The myth underneath the myths
Underneath all of these sits a deeper belief: that there is a trick to restaurants, a set of insider moves that unlocks a better meal than the one on the menu. There mostly is not. Kitchens cook what they cook, in the order tickets arrive, for everyone alike. The real advantages are plain and available to anyone: arrive at a sane hour, order the food the place is built to make, say clearly what you need, and treat the staff like the professionals they are. That is not a trick. It is just dining, done with your eyes open, and it outperforms every hack on the internet.
Common questions
What takeout dishes travel best?
Baked and sealed dishes first: calzones, strombolis, and pizza. Sandwiches travel acceptably. Dressed salads and fries lose the most on the ride.
How long does leftover pizza keep?
Refrigerated promptly, three to four days is the standard food-safety window. Reheat until steaming hot throughout.
Is it rude to order takeout at closing time?
Order with enough time for the kitchen to cook before close. A takeout order placed a few minutes before the doors shut puts the staff in an unfair spot.
← All guides from Court Street Grille← Back to Court Street Grille